I'm using the MACD to spot divergences. I would like to fine tune the fast, slow, and period signals. If you use the MACD, which settings work the best for you?
Most traders use Fast 12, Slow 26, and Sig 9.
Here's a better way. Adjust the MACD values yourself until you find the fewest false signals (head fake where it breaks about 0 only to fall back down again). For example, let's use Download TradingSolutions to do this.
First load in the 1 year's worth of data for IBKR.
Choose all the MACD indicators.
Choose whether you want to play the long side, short side, or both and how much of the stock you want to buy.
With an MACD with the values of 12, 26, and 9, and $500 initial trading capital, I would have made about $12 between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 in IBKR. That's crap.
So rather than use an MACD with 12, 26, 9, I'm going to find a better indicator to work with for IBKR. I repeat the steps above but this time I select all the indicators. Over 600 tests are done, back testing each indicator over the year. Here are the results.
So the Stochastic RSI (10) had 9 trades between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 for a total gain of 7.72%. When overlay the StochRSI over the chart, I can visually see the accuracy of this indicator.
The red down arrows are the sell signals, and the green up arrows are the buy signals. As you can see, a buy signal was given last Friday.
This is how I would go about approaching indicators rather than just having a default one like the MACD 12,26,9 that you use on every stock. One size does not fit all and what you are doing is forcing the trade rather than letting the stock tell you which indicator is the best to use.
I'm using the MACD to spot divergences. I would like to fine tune the fast, slow, and period signals. If you use the MACD, which settings work the best for you?
Most traders use Fast 12, Slow 26, and Sig 9.
Here's a better way. Adjust the MACD values yourself until you find the fewest false signals (head fake where it breaks about 0 only to fall back down again). For example, let's use Download TradingSolutions to do this.
First load in the 1 year's worth of data for IBKR.
Choose all the MACD indicators.
Choose whether you want to play the long side, short side, or both and how much of the stock you want to buy.
With an MACD with the values of 12, 26, and 9, and $500 initial trading capital, I would have made about $12 between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 in IBKR. That's crap.
So rather than use an MACD with 12, 26, 9, I'm going to find a better indicator to work with for IBKR. I repeat the steps above but this time I select all the indicators. Over 600 tests are done, back testing each indicator over the year. Here are the results.
So the Stochastic RSI (10) had 9 trades between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 for a total gain of 7.72%. When overlay the StochRSI over the chart, I can visually see the accuracy of this indicator.
The red down arrows are the sell signals, and the green up arrows are the buy signals. As you can see, a buy signal was given last Friday.
This is how I would go about approaching indicators rather than just having a default one like the MACD 12,26,9 that you use on every stock. One size does not fit all and what you are doing is forcing the trade rather than letting the stock tell you which indicator is the best to use.
I'm using the MACD to spot divergences. I would like to fine tune the fast, slow, and period signals. If you use the MACD, which settings work the best for you?
Most traders use Fast 12, Slow 26, and Sig 9.
Here's a better way. Adjust the MACD values yourself until you find the fewest false signals (head fake where it breaks about 0 only to fall back down again). For example, let's use Download TradingSolutions to do this.
First load in the 1 year's worth of data for IBKR.
Choose all the MACD indicators.
Choose whether you want to play the long side, short side, or both and how much of the stock you want to buy.
With an MACD with the values of 12, 26, and 9, and $500 initial trading capital, I would have made about $12 between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 in IBKR. That's crap.
So rather than use an MACD with 12, 26, 9, I'm going to find a better indicator to work with for IBKR. I repeat the steps above but this time I select all the indicators. Over 600 tests are done, back testing each indicator over the year. Here are the results.
So the Stochastic RSI (10) had 9 trades between 7/2/08 and 4/17/09 for a total gain of 7.72%. When overlay the StochRSI over the chart, I can visually see the accuracy of this indicator.
The red down arrows are the sell signals, and the green up arrows are the buy signals. As you can see, a buy signal was given last Friday.
This is how I would go about approaching indicators rather than just having a default one like the MACD 12,26,9 that you use on every stock. One size does not fit all and what you are doing is forcing the trade rather than letting the stock tell you which indicator is the best to use.
Copyright 2009-2011 GuerillaStockTrading.com All rights reserved. No part or article on this website may be copied or duplicated without written consent from GuerillaStockTrading.com and Confab Publishing. Disclaimer: This Web site is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information on the subject of personal finances. It is provided with the understanding that neither the author nor the publisher is engaged in rendering legal, accounting, or other professional services by providing this Web site. The authors and publisher shall not be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential or other damages. As each individual situation is unique, questions relevant to personal finances and specific to the individual should be addressed to an appropriate professional to ensure that the situation has been carefully and appropriately evaluated. This blog is for information and entertainment purposes only. Under no circumstances does this information represent a recommendation to buy or sell securities or any other type of investment instruments. See a licensed broker for investment advice.